Econintersect sends a nightly newsletter highlighting news events of the day, and providing a summary of new articles posted on the website.

Econintersect will not sell or pass your email address to others per our privacy policy. You can cancel this subscription at any time by selecting the unsubscribing link in the footer of each email.

March 25th, in aa syndicationBusiness, Money and Bankingprices - ppi, cpi, etctrade data. John Maynard Keynes traded currencies using a discretionary and fundamentals-based strategy.

This column shows that he underperformed rules-based carry, momentum and value strategies. The returns to these strategies in the s and s were time-varying and are in part explained by the contemporary limits to arbitrage.

The excess returns might also represent compensation for exposure to the considerable macroeconomic volatility of the time. Until recently, economists thought that currency trading was a zero sum game and that the expected return to currency speculation was zero. Yet recent research has shown that simple, rules-based currency trading strategies have proven very profitable over the last thirty years. All evidence on the returns to currency trading strategies is based on currency markets since the end of Bretton Woods in the s.

There has been no study of the returns to currency speculation across different time periods.

In our recent research we explore the returns to currency trading in another era of pronounced exchange rate volatility: These two decades of active currency trading constitute a natural out-of-sample test of the performance of those currency strategies well-documented in the modern era. Beginning ina large-scale forward currency market emerged in London enabling investors for the first time to trade currencies with the same instruments used in modern exchanges.

Moreover, the economic backdrop of the s and s was markedly different to that of the post-Bretton Woods period. Compared to the relatively benign conditions of the Great Moderation up tothe interwar years exhibited considerable macroeconomic volatility, providing a substantial challenge to the floating exchange rategold standardand managed floating regimes alike.

Well-known for his contributions to exchange rate theory, Keynes was also an active currency trader during the s and s.

He made full use of the newly-emerged forward market to bet on the evolution of spot exchange rates. First, he was an informed trader and an expert on currency markets. Evidence of his success as a stock investor also suggests he had superior trading skills Chambers, Dimson, and Foo Using archival data on his currency trading, we for the first time provide a detailed analysis of his strategy and performance.

If You're So Smart: John Maynard Keynes and Currency Speculation in the Interwar Years | The Journal of Economic History | Cambridge Core

Our first main finding is that the outsized returns to the carry credit risk in fx options momentum trading strategies present today also exist in the period. Returns to the value strategy were on the other hand consistently poor. Over the whole period, carry and momentum strategies generated mean annualized excess forex forward booking of These findings are robust to controlling for transaction costs, which account for no more than one-third of the gross excess 60 second binary options strategy mt4 to carry and momentum.

Figure 1 displays the cumulative log excess returns of carry and momentum strategies over the returns to currency speculation evidence from keynes the trader entire period against those on UK stocks.

Both strategies generated particularly high returns in the s, relative to contemporary stocks and bonds and to the same currency strategies in the s and s. Cumulative excess returns to carry and momentum Notes: By contrast, we find no evidence that Keynes followed any of the carry or momentum strategies. His writings indicate that his currency trading was based on a discretionary analysis of macro-economic fundamentals such as expected changes in official interest rates, the inflation outlook, and the level of European reparations and international capital flows.

Keynes also leveraged his contacts when forming his currency views. His correspondence reveals that he attempted to exploit information gleaned during his meetings with diplomats, bankers, and stakeholders involved in important currency discussions. The GBP position is equivalent to his net long or short position in all other currencies.

Consistent with his concerns about the performance of European economies and currencies struggling under the reparations burden, he constantly shorted the French franc FRFGerman mark DEM and Italian the returns to currency speculation evidence from keynes the trader ITL from to Inhe mainly traded in the US dollar USD where he alternated between short and long positions. Having shorted the dollar in October Februaryhe closed his position on 2 Marchjust eight days before the suspension of US dollar gold convertibility.

He then went long the dollar between April and June only to see the currency depreciate. His other trades were short positions in the French franc FRF and the Dutch florin NLG from mid until these currencies were devalued in September Given he was informed and among the first to understand the new forward exchange market, Keynes ought to have been well placed to succeed as a currency trader.

Was he able to beat the naive carry and momentum strategies? Over the whole period he traded during benefits of auto binary options trading services s and s, we estimate Keynes achieved a considerably lower average return 5.

This underperformance was mostly concentrated in the s. In the s, he managed to beat the carry trade but still unperformed the momentum strategy and was unable to match the returns on UK stocks and bonds. The recent literature has proposed several explanations for the performance of these strategies in the post-Bretton Woods period.

Out-of-Sample Evidence on the Returns to Currency Trading by Olivier Accominotti, David Chambers :: SSRN

We present evidence to suggest that, similar to today, the returns to these strategies in the s and s are time-varying and are in part explained by the limits to arbitrage experienced by contemporary currency traders. We also provide evidence that the excess returns to the carry strategy might represent compensation to investors for their exposure to the considerable macroeconomic volatility of the s and s.

Jorda, Oscar, and Alan M. The growing use of ad blocking software is creating a shortfall in covering our fixed expenses.

Please consider a donation to Econintersect to allow continuing output of quality and balanced financial and economic news and analysis. This Web Page by Steven Hansen Copyright - Econintersect LLC - all rights reserved. Evidence from Keynes the Trader March 25th, in aa syndicationBusiness, Money and Bankingprices - ppi, cpi, etctrade data.

The returns to currency speculation: Evidence from Keynes the trader | VOX, CEPR’s Policy Portal

Carry trade, which borrows in low interest rate currencies and invests in high interest rate currencies Lustig and VerdelhanBurnside et al. Currency speculation in the s and s All evidence on the returns to currency trading strategies is based on currency markets since the end of Bretton Woods in the s. Having compiled a detailed data set of month-end forward foreign exchange bid and ask quotations for all major currencies in the s and s, we first explore the returns to carry, momentum, and value strategies.

Second, we compare the returns to these rules-based strategies with the strategy of a sophisticated currency trader of the period: Carry, momentum, and value strategies in the s and s Our first main finding is that the outsized returns to the carry and momentum trading strategies present today also exist in the period. Click to enlarge Consistent with his concerns about the performance of European economies and currencies struggling under the reparations burden, he constantly shorted the French franc FRFGerman mark DEM and Italian lira ITL from to Keep up with economic news using our dynamic economic newspapers with the largest international coverage on the internet.

Blogs Analysis Blog News Blog Investing Blog Opinion Blog Precious Metals Blog Markets Blog Video of the Day Weather.